Non-speech behaviours in neurogenic stuttering

Thumbnail Image
Issue Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Neurogenic stuttering is characterised by the occurrence of speech disfluencies following neurological brain damage. While people with a developmental onset of stuttering typically present with non-speech behaviours associated with their stuttering (e.g. eye blinking, facial grimacing), it has been argued that such behaviours are absent in people with a neurological onset of stuttering (Helm-Estabrooks, 1999). However, a number of case-studies suggested otherwise (e.g., Tani and Sakai (2010), Vanhoutte et al. (2014)). This study aimed to investigate, for the first time, the non-speech behaviours in a larger group of people with neurogenic stuttering. This study consisted of 22 participants with a diagnosis of neurogenic stuttering and a control group of 17 healthy older adults. Their speech was analysed by annotating all stuttering-like disfluencies (SLD), other disfluencies (OD) and non-speech behaviours (NSB). For each non-speech behaviour, duration and severity was also coded. The results showed that the frequency of occurrence of non-speech behaviours was higher within the neurogenic stuttering group (M = .12, SD = .13) compared to the control group (M = .02, SD =.19). The duration and severity of the NSBs were also different between the groups. SLDs were a significant predictor of proportion of NSBs (β = .4, t = 3.39, p .01) and duration of NSBs (β =.43, t = 2.9, p .01), as well as of a score combining all three NSB measurements (β = .5, t = 4.05, p .001). In a model without outliers, the severity of NSBs was also significantly predicted by SLD proportion (β = .67, t = 5.46, p .001). Within the neurogenic stuttering group, SLDs were the most important predictor of the combined NSB score (βSLD = .41, tSLD = 3.2, pSLD .01) and the proportion of NSBs (β = .34, t = 2.32, p =.03). The results show that non-speech behaviours do occur more frequently and are more severe in people with neurogenic stuttering compared to a control group of healthy speakers. This is in contrast with previous publications stating that non-speech behaviours do not present in neurogenic stuttering. Time post-onset and emotions and attitudes associate with speech were not significant predictors of the proportion of NSBs, contradicting the theory that NSBs develop as a reaction to stuttering.
Faculteit der Letteren